Blue Dog Bakery Natural Dog Treats, Softies, Peanut Butter Flavor, 16.2oz Bag, 1 Bag

Oh Boy do my dogs love these! They are soft and chewy, and they are a perfect size for a treat. The dogs just gobble them up, then want more, but they are a good size that one is enough. Also. It's a large bag, and they treats came in great shape. They are a little harder on the outside, and soft on the inside, so there was hardly any breakage when they were delivered.

I'm not even sure how many bags of these Peanut Butter treats I've ordered over the last couple of years. ALL of our foster dogs just love them! We have not had a single one turn their nose up at them, and we've had a couple of very picky eaters in the house. They smell delicious! I smell more molasses than peanut butter, but either way, they smell like they should be for humans instead of for dogs. And they're quite soft. If you have a bag that's been open for a while, even if you seal it up well, they still tend to get a bit firmer, but none of the dogs seem to mind at all!

Our dogs really love these peanut butter nuggets (the size of a fig newton cookie) in their dog food as a treat each evening. They love the flavor of these. I have also used them for training / reward cookies for them. These are soft and chewable, perfect for senior dogs too. The value for the treats is really affordable and the quality is evident in the size of these treats, too. I ordered more during the recent sale to have some back up treats, lol! But seriously - can spoiled hard, working hunting dogs be rewarded with less than great treats - I think not! Thank you for your quality product.

If your old dog starts struggling to eat his hard food (aka "kibble") due to tooth loss, this is a pretty nice option to help ensure that he/she is getting much-needed supplemental nutrients as you convert over to soft food. My dog loves the taste, but due to the hardness of the snack bites, I have to break it down into very small crumbs in order for him to be able to eat it…pairs nicely with small pieces of whole wheat bread.

My dogs eat these treats whole and want more! The fact that they are soft makes them easier to eat and our older dog doesn't have any issues. I like that they are natural, makes it easy to feel good when I give them more treats.

My dog loves these treats. So, for the record, my ratings for the flavor, ingredients, and value for the money are high. The reason for the overall three star review is because they were all stale. The consistency of the treat is supposed to be soft and I haven't had a bag of them that wasn't soft until this one, the first time I ordered them through Amazon. Upon initially opening the bag and getting a few in my hand, I could immediately feel the difference. They had no softness to them when I squeezed them between my thumb and forefinger. When I pulled one apart, ir didn't pull apart as a soft baked product. Rather, it snapped apart quickly as if dried out. I checked the USE BY date and it was well into the future. I checked to see if the bag was air tight and it was. They smelled fine. My dog happily enjoyed them with no digestive issue. I would definitely recommend this treat for your pup. I will order them again via Amazon to see if there is a similar consistency issue with the product. It could have very well been a one-off issue with that one bag. We shall see!

There liked.

My dog loced these but disliked the crunchy paws or whatever the other variety's called

My dog likes these! He is fussy over the type of treats he gets. Beef not so much, chicken, peanut butter and cheese is his loves. These have peanut butter and a soft chew. He likes 4 please!