Italia Deluxe Matte Liquid Eyeliner Waterproof (3pcs)

I took a chance on this eyeliner since NYX black matte eyeliner got reformulated to my great disappointment. I read in an another review here that this is a great dupe, and boy, were they right! I love the amount I get for the price, the formula of the eyeliner smells good as well. This formula is very easy to apply for myself. I get no eye irritation from using this brand, and although the eyeliner is not waterproof, it definitely stays on and is matte as advertised. I think I have to take more time to test the durability of the formula after a night out. Overall, so happy I went with this brand! It really does make an amazing dupe to nyx matte black eyeliner and I’m so happy to get three bottles for a cheap price. Thank you! :)

I absolutely love this matte eyeliner. It’s incredibly affordable and lasts me the entire day. Applying it is incredibly easy.

Due to unfortunate circumstances and me taking 100 percent of the shots given I now spend my days in front of a camera talking. A lot. Which is exactly why I bought this eyeliner. First of all my mom was right “it’s this dang phone.” I saw a baddie on TikTok raving about this eyeliner being matte waterproof and perfect for watery eyes. So naturally I said heck yeah opened Amazon and added to cart. Now here’s where things went left. I am lazy and I am always running late ADHD and time blindness am I right. Because of that I had been using the Stila Stay All Day marker tip liner since most days I’m applying lipstick and eyeliner in the car. The issue is my eyes are sensitive to life. Anything makes them water so that liner would run. I bought this eyeliner hoping for no smudging and maybe looking like I have my life together. Let me say this. This eyeliner is black as 11:59 PM and very matte. Once it dries it looks amazing. However if you do not have a steady hand it does take some time to get used to applying. This is not a quick swipe and go liner at first. Once you get the hang of it though the payoff is worth it. But once applied the burning starts. It feels like rubbing your eyes after cutting up a Carolina Reaper. I genuinely do not recall signing a waiver for that level of spice and pain. I thought my eyes watered before but no. Now they water because they are actually burning. On top of that my nose starts running. So not only am I tearing up but I’m also snotting like a toddler after their first week in daycare. As Beyoncé said “Pretty hurts.” So I fan my eyes wait for it to dry let the tearing stop then clean up anything that ran with concealer and a small flat angled brush. Blow my nose touch up my foundation and leave because of course I am late. That said this eyeliner lasts. It lasts all day through naps and even through crying while watching All Dogs Go to Heaven. I remove my makeup with a cleansing balm so I cannot say how easily water alone removes it but once it is on it is not going anywhere. ✨Oily skin tip✨ If you are oily lightly dust setting powder where you plan to line. Let it sit for about a minute then gently dust away the excess before applying the liner. This makes a huge difference in longevity. Chef’s kiss. It does not move. No smudging! In summary I am not sure if this review is meant to persuade or warn you. Either way I love this eyeliner. TLDR::: Very black very matte and truly waterproof. Lasts all day through naps and tears. If you have sensitive eyes be aware it burns briefly on application. Once dry it stays put. Painful at first but effective.

NOT WATERPROOF!! BUT I LOVE IT!! i’ve been wearing this eyeliner for yearsss, im just a fan of the brush tip easy application, it’s fast drying and last all day, but i promise you the minute you start crying or wash your face, the eyeliner come off with no problem, YOU will be left with racoon eyes so it does stick to you, just not waterproof like said but looks like they’ve changed the bottle, i’ve noticed is they’re now giving you 0.23oz instead of the original 0.25oz so do what with that information

Best liquid eyeliner lasts all day and isn’t dry or flakey

I like that it dries matte and the ink is very dark. I also like the price for the amount of product. I didn't like that it wasn't really waterproof and it flakes off a little. I also didn't like how the applicator is square at the end and not to a point. It makes application of the product messy and the lines aren't precise. I use eyeliner daily and have been doing it for years and I like a nice pointy wing and I like my eyeliner to be a clean line and precise. I found it difficult to do that with this product. If you like a nice thick eyeliner line then this product is good for that, however, if you have trouble applying liquid eyeliner in general, then I recommend not using this product.

Finally, an eyeliner brush thin and detailed enough to do the designs I like to draw around my eyes! May not be the most waterproof out there but they are more waterproof than the Elf eyeliner, which is good enough for me.

When it comes to precision and how thin the wing comes out i give it a 5 star. But it’s not waterproof at all!!! so that was disappointing. I would come home with half of my wing off half of the time. (My eyes get watery when i yawn) so that doesn’t help