Fat Cat Yada Yadas Talkin' Dog Toy

I bought this toy back in February for my then 3 month old Dane puppy, Jax. I didn't have a choice of which toy but ened up with the frog. He LOVES this thing. It "ribbits" like a frog. So after almost 5 months of rough chewing and playing this frog is only down 2 legs which did not cause him to become unstuffed. As a matter of fact I threw it in the wash today and it's still going strong. 5 stars because it's been durable and he loves it. I will be buying another one when this one finally bites the dust.

Our dog loved her fish (it makes a bubbling sound) and hoped to get a replacement. .Rolled the dice hoping for a fish but got the duck which is also OK but not as liked as the fish was (Frog was least desired choice) . If they ever offer a choice (vs luck of the draw), I'll try ordering a fish. 1 star deduction for not getting to select which one you will get.

You don't get to pick what you want. We received the frog. I purchased this toy because it came up when I searched for tiny dog or small dog toys. Well, this toy is NOT small by any means. It's made for a large dog. My two chihuahuas can not play with this because they can not fit it in their mouths. Does make a cute rib it sound when you squeeze it but that does my dogs no good. It actually frightens them because the toy is so big.

What does the frog say? Rib-bit. That is it. The entire vocabulary consists of a rib-bit. I have plenty of other "talking" dog toys and they are much more "talkative" than this. It is well constructed, and my dog likes the texture and the stuffing, but for the cost, I expected a talking frog. Not a simple today the makes a frog noise. Nothing interesting about this. Cost benefit analysis will leave you feeling like you kissed a lot of frogs and still have not found a prince.

The toys are tough, my dog didn't destroy it. But the sound finally quit working after several months. I had ordered a second one and received another fish, same as the first. You don't get a choice when ordering. The dog does like it, the bubbly noise the fish made intrigued her for awhile. If I had a choice, I might order a third (would like the frog), but won't since I don't want another fish.

Fat Cat toys are the absolute best. They are they only toys that will hold up. My dog destroys all the other toys within minutes, including the Kong todys

my dog enjoys the fish toy. it's a little hard to get to make noise like I had hoped it would but it's durable and he hasn't been able to destroy it yet.

Very misleading. The picture implies this is a combo pack of three. Nowhere in the description does it say the customer will only receive one of the three shown (seller's choice). If there was a drop down box to allow the customer to pick the particular toy, it would have been obvious. What a ripoff.